Is it Better to Have Capital Gains or Dividends? Here’s What You Need to Know

One of the most common questions investors face is whether earning income from capital gains or dividends is better. Both of these income types have their advantages, but they also come with different tax treatments and long-term effects on your portfolio.

Understanding these basic concepts and tax effects can help you make more fruitful decisions when managing your investments.

Overview: Capital Gains vs. Dividend Income

Before discussing the specifics, let’s define capital gains and dividends to understand precisely how they work.

• Capital Gains: This refers to the profits you make when you sell assets/stocks, such as stocks, real estate, or any other investment, for a higher price than you paid. For example, if you buy 100 shares of a stock for $10 per share and later sell them for $15, your capital gain would be $5 per share or $500 in total.
• Dividend Income: Dividends are a part of a company’s profits paid to its shareholders. Companies often pay dividends to share their earnings with investors who own their stocks. If you own shares in a company, you may receive regular payments from that company. For example, a company may pay $1 per share every quarter, so if you own 100 shares, you would receive $100 in dividend income.

Check Your Capital Gains Tax – Short-Term and Long-Term (Use Calculator)

---

Capital Gains: What Are They and How Are They Taxed?

Capital gains are a critical part of most investment strategies. Investors aim to sell their investments at a higher price than they purchased them for, and the difference is the capital gain.

How Capital Gains Work:

You make a capital gain or profit when you sell an asset for more than you paid. For example, if you paid $50 per share for a stock and sold the stock for $100, that is a capital gain of $50 per share. The more assets you sell at higher prices than you pay for them, the more significant your capital gains.

Also read this Article to Know More – Capital Gains Tax Simplified: Short-Term vs. Long-Term & Ways to Reduce Your Tax Bill

Taxing Capital Gains:

The tax you pay on capital gains or profits depends on two main factors:

• Holding Period: The first thing that will help determine how much you will owe in taxes is how long you hold an investment before selling it. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) separates short-term and long-term capital gains based on your holding period.
  • Short-Term Capital Gains: The gain is considered short-term if you sell an asset within one year or less of purchasing it. These are paid according to your ordinary income tax rate, which will depend on your income. They can be 10% to 37% of your ordinary income tax rate. This means short-term capital gains can be taxed relatively high, especially for higher-income earners.
  • Long-Term Capital Gains: If you hold the stocks/assets for over a year before selling them, profits are taxed as long-term capital gains. Long-term capital gains have more favorable tax rates: 0%, 15%, or 20%, based on your income level. The higher your income, the higher the tax rate within that range. These lower tax rates can significantly reduce your tax burden, so investors often favor long-term investments.

Why Holding Long-Term Is Beneficial: The benefit of long-term capital gains is that the tax rates are generally lower than ordinary income tax rates. Therefore, you can keep more profits by holding onto investments for at least a year.

---

Dividend Income: What Are They and How Are They Taxed?

Another way investors make money from their investments is through dividend income. Instead of selling an asset, you receive regular payments from the institution you are invested in. However, like capital gains, dividends are also taxed.

Grow your Income with Dividends; ABALX offers more dividends: How Often Does ABALX Pay Dividends?

How Dividend Income Works:

When you own shares in a company that pays dividends, the company may distribute part of its profits to shareholders. For example, if a company has a profit of $1,000,000 and decides to pay out 30% of that to shareholders, it will distribute $300,000 in total. If you own 1% of the company’s shares, you would receive 1% of $300,000, or $3,000.

Taxing Dividend Income:

Dividend income can be taxed in two ways, depending on whether the dividend is considered ordinary or qualified.

1. Ordinary Dividends: These are dividends that do not meet the requirements for special tax treatment. They are taxed at the same rate as your ordinary income, which means they are taxed at rates ranging from 10% to 37%. Most dividends paid by U.S. companies are ordinary dividends.
2. Qualified Dividends: These dividends satisfy unique criteria that subject them to lower tax rates, such as long-term capital gains. The tax rates are based upon your taxable income and may range from 0% to 20% Max. This tax treatment generally applies to dividends paid by qualified foreign corporations and the United States of America, rendering them more advantageous than ordinary dividends.

The Advantage of Qualified Dividends: If you can invest in companies that pay qualified dividends, you can benefit from the lower tax rates, which makes dividend income more tax-efficient.

Check this Worksheet provided by the IRS: Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet—Keep for Your Records

---

Practical Considerations: Which One is Better for You?

Consider your objectives, time horizon, and tax savings when considering whether dividends or capital gains are better for you. Here is what you must know.

• 1.  Your Investment Goals:
  • Capital picks benefits are more interesting if you’re interested in development and the need to gather wealth over time.
  • Offering resources for a benefit permits your cash to develop, and long-term capital gains tax rates incentivise you to hold investments longer.
  • If you require income from your ventures, profits are an excellent source of customary instalments without providing anything. This can help if you need the venture to pay to live or reinvest it.

• 2.  Tax Efficiency:
  • Long-term capital gains and qualified dividends are the most tax-efficient because they get taxed at much lower rates.
  • Short-term capital profits and ordinary dividends are taxed at higher rates, so those can reduce the amount of income you keep after taxes.

• 3.  Holding Period:
  • Holding investments for an extended period can minimize capital gains and dividend tax rates. Most long-term investors target a portfolio with more capital gains and qualified dividends.

• 4.  Portfolio Strategy:
  • Dividend investors and Profit financial specialists may focus on stocks that pay steady and qualified dividends, which provide income while keeping taxes low.
  • Growth financial specialists might prioritize capital picks by contributing to stocks that have the potential to increase in value over time.

Try Google Finance tools for your Investment Strategies – Is Google Finance Good? Why Google Finance is Your Best Investment Tool 2024

---

Bottom Line

There is no simple answer to whether it is preferable to have capital gains or dividends because both forms of income have pros and cons relative to your goals. Capital gains may be better if you seek long-term growth and do not need the money immediately. However, if you need regular income from your investments, dividends (exceptionally qualified ones) provide a consistent cash flow with favorable tax treatment.

Combining capital gains and dividend income strategies could achieve the best of both worlds. You will understand how each type of income is taxed and plan your investment strategy accordingly, maximizing your after-tax returns to ensure that your investment strategy aligns with your financial objectives.

If you’re unsure which approach is best for your tax situation, asking a financial advisor or tax consultant for help making the most tax-efficient choices is always a good idea.